@alyx The problem with recommendations is always that not only is everyone different but something I read at a certain time in my life and enjoyed might be something I would have hated at a different time. Like sometimes all I want to read is predictable fantasy with worn tropes so I can just enjoy some nice words and characters doing stuff without any surprises.
I believe there is no book out there that is "truly great" all the time. Just the ones that work for you or that do not work for you at a certain time.
@schonwiedersamstag those are definitely factors, agreed, but i think there is also an inherent quality or lack thereof in any given book. bad writing is bad writing. i will never enjoy a mass-market star wars novel (tried some acclaimed ones) or the latest six-monther from R.A. Salvatore
my ex, on the other hand, ate that stuff up. our book tastes were different.