I don't talk about religion much. I feel like I wanna do that today.
I'm an atheist. I don't talk about it much because I was raised in a 6 generation deep southern baptist family on one side, and by the daughter of an eastern orthodox archpriest on the other.
My family is deeply religious.
My dad has a degree in theology, and taught the youth groups for most of my life. He sang in a gospel group with the word "faithful" in the name (which is where he met his second wife. #irony.)
But I left all that 10 years ago.
There are a lot of things that churches provide that I miss.
Don't get me wrong, I don't miss the bigotry and the abuse of power (which, at the end of the day, is like 80% of most churches)
But I miss the sense of family and community.
I miss having people I could rely on in a pinch. I miss feeling like the creator had a master plan. I miss the worship.
Let's talk about worship.
Worship services do weird things to your brain.
You know that feeling you get at a concert, when Alison Mosshart (or whoever you care about) looks out in to the audience and it feels like she's looking right in to your soul as she sings "baby says"? (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jfLcPYA3Nlk)
You know that feeling of oneness, stillness, that comes with losing yourself in that crowd? Singing along? Worshiping at the altar of rock?
Imagine getting that every week.
It's hella addictive.
You sing along, you take part, you listen to intelligent people deeply analyze and study and lecture and you feel like you're a part of something bigger than yourself.
Except that, I don't anymore. I had to go to a church service out of social obligation a few years ago, and I felt angry and uncomfortable the entire time.
I saw the tricks the charlatan was using, the gaps in logic, the propaganda. It made me sick.
On the way home, I followed out the arguments that the pastor had made to their logical extremes.
Out loud, to everyone.
I deconstructed the entire sermon down in to, essentially, "when bad things happen, it's god punishing you. Therefore, Obama is god punishing us."
The people in the car told me to shut up, and that I clearly wasn't "receptive" to the "word of god"
And shit does it ever make me mad when people use "the word of god" or "god's will" as an excuse for being dicks.
My aunt, when I asked the world in general if anyone could pick me up and take me to work one day, after my car broke down, told me she would pray for me.
She lived less than a mile away, was at home, had no plans.
When I asked her directly, she said she didn't feel like getting out of bed.
@ajroach42 I would have been merciless. "Oh, feeling the sin of sloth heavily on you today huh. Tell you what, forget praying for ME, pray for your fucking self"
@ajroach42 there's a line in C. S. Lewis's "Screwtape Letters" about how prayer can so easily turn into "dwelling on those aspects of a person you happen to dislike"
@ajroach42 same! I think I have reached peace with my admiration of him, though. We hit some of the same milestones that he described in "Surprised by Joy", but I decided that they led me down a different path, away from a religion in which I never could find much spiritual nourishment.
@kara_dreamer I mean, every belief system has a similar myth, and many of those predate christianity by a lot.
I've always found that argument pretty weak, too.
@ajroach42 well, chronology wouldn't really mean much here, to a timeless god. like, if (say) Baldur is an "echo" of Jesus, that echo could occur anywhere in time, backwards or forwards. Stokes and anti-Stokes *chuckles* (sorry, little chemistry humor there)
@ajroach42 I was never, ever able to come at all close to convincing myself, as it seems Tolkien convinced Lewis, that the reason Lewis felt a strong emotional pull towards pagan stories of gods dying and reborn is because they were mere echoes of the TRUE god dying and reborn. The Jesus story just seems far too limited and uninspiring for that. if that's the _real_ story then why does it do nothing for me